Court Rules It Was ‘Reasonable’ For Cop To Shoot Dog For Barking

A dog killed in a raid was “just standing there” when an officer shot her.

Court Rules It Was Reasonable For Cop To Shoot Dog For BarkingA federal appeals court has sided with police officers who fatally shot two dogs during a drug raid, even though officers testified that one of the dogs was merely barking and “just standing there.”

Mark and Cheryl Brown of Battle Creek, Michigan, first brought a lawsuit against the City of Battle Creek, the city’s police department and three officers in 2015, the Battle Creek Enquirer reports.

A drug raid gone awry had resulted in their two dogs being killed two years prior.

The Browns argued that the police killing their pets constituted unreasonable seizure under the Fourth Amendment.

A lower court dismissed the suit, and on Wednesday, the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati released an opinion upholding the lower court’s decision.

Neither Mark nor Cheryl Brown was a criminal suspect. But police obtained a warrant to search their residence because they had received reports that a man named Vincent Jones had been distributing cocaine and heroin from the home.

The owner of the home was Cheryl Brown’s mother, who had a child with Jones.

Police said they received word on the way to the residence that Jones had already been arrested and was in custody. They also learned that Mark Brown — who was on his lunch break from work — was at the house, and that there was a dog in the backyard.

Officers handcuffed Brown in front of the home when they arrived. Brown testified that he informed one of the officers that his two dogs were inside, and offered them keys to the place.

Officer Christof Klein, who later said he hadn’t heard Brown offer his keys, used a large metal ram to open the door.

Klein also testified that the two dogs, described as pit bulls, were barking “aggressively” and “lunging towards the windows” before officers entered the home, although Brown disputed this claim.

The remainder of the account of the raid comes from testimony by the police officers involved.

Klein said the first dog continued barking aggressively and “lunged” at him when he went inside, although he specified the “lunge” only involved the dog moving “a few inches.” At that point, he shot and wounded the dog. Both dogs then retreated into the basement.

The officers then entered the basement in order to “sweep” the place for drugs and possible other suspects. When the wounded dog at the bottom of the stairs began barking again, Klein shot and killed her.

See also: Dogs Are Now Recognized As Sentient Beings In France

At this point, the second dog was standing in the middle of the basement. Klein testified that she started barking while standing still and facing away from the officers. He fired two shots at her, and she ran to the basement’s back corner.

Officer Damon Young said he shot the dog when she started “moving” away from the corner and toward him. The dog ran behind a furnace, at which point Officer Jeffrey Case fatally shot her. He said didn’t want to see her continue to suffer and that there was “blood coming out of numerous holes” in her body.

Judge Eric Clay wrote in the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals opinion that shooting both dogs was “reasonable” because the animals were preventing the officers from “safely” sweeping the basement. Clay also wrote that the officers did not have enough time to come up with a plan to deal with the dogs in the home.

Battle Creek Police Chief Jim Blocker told the Battle Creek Enquirer that it was “a good ruling” that “pointed out some things we have to improve upon, but supported our operating concept that officers must act within reason.”

Dog trainer Brian Kilcommons, who has collaborated with the Department of Justice on improving police encounters with dogs, disagrees. He called the ruling “beyond the scope of sanity.”

Law enforcement officials frequently mistake signs of fear for aggression, Kilcommons said. The fact that the dogs ran away from the officers and into the basement was much more “telling” than any barking, he said, no matter how aggressive it may have sounded.

“In such a high-tension situation, expecting a dog not to bark is just plain stupid,” he told The Huffington Post. “The worst thing according to this precedent is that every dog barks when a stranger shows up.”

Final thoughts

What’s next? Shooting a child because its crying? And No… its not reasonable for cops to shoot dogs unless the dog is charging after them ready to jump and rip off their heads.

Find us here

Get news from the CSGLOBE in your inbox each weekday morning

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors/source and do not necessarily reflect the position of CSGLOBE or its staff.

Paid content

14 African Countries Who Still Pay Colonial Tax To France

80% of the 10 countries with the lowest literacy rates in the WORLD among adults are in francophone Africa. Namely: Benin (40%), Burkina Faso (26%),...

High-speed pig slaughter will be disastrous for everyone involved

The Trump administration has proposed a radical change in food safety protection. They’re misleadingly calling it the “Modernization of swine slaughter inspection rule”, but what...

After Cops Stole His Cash for Selling Unlawful Hot Dogs, The Internet Gave Him $70,000

Berkeley police are in the spotlight this week after one of their officers not only cited a man for selling hot dogs to willing...

What's New Today

Georgia House Votes To Allow Citizens To Abolish Police Departments In The State

The Georgia House backed an effort on Friday to dissolve the Glynn County Police Department and any...

Leaked CDC document contradicts Pence claim that U.S. coronavirus cases ‘have stabilized’

Even as Vice President Mike Pence wrote in a Wall Street Journal op-ed published Tuesday that coronavirus...

Five bombshells about Trump from Bolton ‘s book

Excerpts from former national security adviser John Bolton ’s book about his time in the Trump administration...

Don’t Listen to Fox. Here’s What’s Really Going On in Seattle’s Protest Zone.

It seems I live in a city undergoing a “totalitarian takeover” that will lead to “fascist outcomes”...


Ancient Paintings of UFO’s from 200 to 15.000 years ago

Ancient Paintings of UFO's Over the past 15,000 years UFOs have been clearly depicted in paintings from all around the world. This video features some...

Out of the Blue

OUT OF THE BLUE is widely considered one of the best documentary films ever made about UFOs and was directed by celebrated filmmakers James...

What Is Agenda 21? Depopulation of 95% of the World By 2030

Most people are unaware that one of the greatest threats to their freedom may be a United Nations program which plans to depopulate 95%...

14 African Countries Who Still Pay Colonial Tax To France

80% of the 10 countries with the lowest literacy rates in the WORLD among adults are in francophone Africa. Namely: Benin (40%), Burkina Faso (26%),...

6 Crimes Against Nature Perpetrated By The Food Industry

While many procedures on factory farms are cruel, breeding animals into mutants and violating mother/offspring bonds are truly crimes against nature. The horrors of factory...

Fukushima Fish Are Up To 124X Above Safe Level

Enjoy The Radioactive Fish Are you purchasing radioactive fish at the grocery store? Are you absolutely certain that you know the answer to that question?...

Monsanto Reports $156 Million Loss in Q4

Big Win! Monsanto Reports $156 Million Loss in Q4 as Farmers Abandon GM Crops Are you invested in Monsanto stock like Bill Gates, who owns...

The Six Most Evil Presidents in U.S. History

Evil, like beauty, is sometimes in the eye of the beholder. It is difficult to distinguish an evil act from an evil person. Few...

What The Cancer Industry Does Not Want You To Know

The Cancer Industry Does Not Want You To Know About Chemotherapy and Radiation They tell us chemotherapy saves lives, boosts long-term survival rates and does...

Scientists Investigating the Impact of Plastic

Scientists investigating the impact of plastic ‘hidden’ in the seas – Biologists discuss the effect of the entry of toxic substances into the food...

14 African Countries Who Still Pay Colonial Tax To France

80% of the 10 countries with the lowest literacy rates in the WORLD among adults are in francophone Africa. Namely: Benin (40%), Burkina Faso (26%),...